Why reference checks and police checks matter when hiring
Recruiting the right people is one of the most important decisions an organisation makes.
A good hire brings skills, experience and fresh perspectives. A poor one can mean extra recruitment costs, lost productivity, disruption to teams and workplace risk.
Interviews and CV reviews help employers judge suitability, but they don’t always give the full picture. That is where pre-employment screening, including reference checks and police checks, comes in.
These checks help organisations verify relevant information, understand a candidate’s background and make better-informed hiring decisions before the employment relationship begins. Built into a structured recruitment process, they also improve consistency and support workplace safety.
What are pre-employment checks?
Pre-employment checks are screening activities during recruitment that help verify what a candidate has told you and assess their suitability for a position.
The checks needed depend on the role, industry, organisation and any legal or regulatory requirements. Common ones include:
- Employment reference checks
- National police checks
- Identity verification
- Employment history verification
- Qualification and education checks
- Professional licence and registration checks
- Right-to-work checks
- Other role-specific background screening
Not every position needs every check. Organisations should decide which checks are relevant and proportionate to the responsibilities and risks of each role.
7 benefits of reference checks and police checks
1. Make more informed hiring decisions
A CV and an interview are only part of the picture. Reference checks add insight from people who have worked with the candidate. They may help you understand:
- Previous responsibilities and duties
- Relevant skills and experience
- Work performance and reliability
- Communication and teamwork
- Professional conduct
- Strengths and development areas
Where appropriate, a police check gives a separate type of information that may be relevant to suitability for a particular position. Weighing these sources alongside interviews, qualifications and experience supports better decisions.
2. Verify employment history and experience
Hiring decisions often rest on what candidates say about their previous roles, responsibilities and achievements. A reference check is a chance to confirm the relevant parts: the previous position, length of employment, responsibilities and experience.
This is especially useful for specialised or senior roles, and for positions of trust, where previous experience is a key selection criterion.
The goal is not just to spot discrepancies. It is to build a clearer understanding of the candidate’s background and suitability.
3. Support a safer workplace
Creating a safe workplace is an important employer responsibility. Depending on the position, organisations may need to consider whether a candidate’s background is relevant to the work they will do and the people they will deal with.
Police checks may form part of an appropriate screening process for roles involving sensitive information, financial authority, vulnerable people or other specific risks.
A police check is not a guarantee that a person presents no risk. It is one source of information, and it should be considered alongside other recruitment and risk-management processes. Employers should also make sure any screening requirement is appropriate for the role and applied fairly.
4. Reduce recruitment and employment risks
A poor hire can cost far more than replacing one employee. Depending on the role, inadequate screening may expose an organisation to:
- Misrepresented qualifications or experience
- Unsuitable access to confidential information
- Risks around financial or operational responsibilities
- Workplace safety concerns
- Reputational damage
- Disruption to business operations
Reference checks and relevant background screening help organisations identify information that needs a closer look before the final decision. They should be part of a broader recruitment process, not the only measure of suitability.
5. Protect organisational reputation and trust
Employees represent the organisation through their work, their dealings with customers and their relationships with colleagues. For roles involving public trust, financial responsibility, sensitive information or direct contact with vulnerable people, employers may have extra reasons to screen.
A consistent, well-documented recruitment process helps show that the relevant considerations were taken into account. It also builds confidence in your recruitment practices among employees, customers and other stakeholders.
6. Create a consistent recruitment process
Without a structured approach, checks get handled differently across departments and hiring managers. Some candidates are asked for references, others face extra screening, requests are delayed, results end up in different places and follow-up gets missed.
A consistent process makes sure the right checks happen at the right stage. Organisations should define:
- Which roles require reference checks
- Which roles require police checks or other screening
- When checks should be requested
- Who is responsible for reviewing results
- How candidates are informed and give consent
- How screening outcomes are documented and stored
- How concerns or discrepancies are assessed
This improves accountability and keeps recruitment manageable as the organisation grows.
7. Improve the overall quality of recruitment
Effective recruitment is about more than filling a vacancy. It is about finding people with the right skills, experience, qualifications and suitability for the position.
Combining structured interviews, reference checks, relevant background screening and qualification verification gives a more complete assessment of a candidate. That supports a more considered selection and lets organisations hire with greater confidence.
Reference checks vs police checks: what’s the difference?
Both are used in pre-employment screening, but they serve different purposes.
| Check type | What it helps establish | Typical purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Employment reference check | Information about a candidate’s previous work experience and performance | Understand previous responsibilities, skills and workplace conduct |
| National police check | Relevant disclosable criminal history information under the applicable checking framework | Assess information relevant to the requirements of a particular role |
| Qualification check | Whether a candidate holds relevant qualifications | Verify education, training and professional credentials |
| Employment history check | Details of previous employment | Confirm relevant work history |
| Identity verification | Whether identity information can be verified | Help establish that the candidate is who they say they are |
| Licence or registration check | Whether relevant credentials or registrations are current | Confirm eligibility for roles requiring specific credentials |
These checks complement each other rather than replace one another. The right combination depends on the position and the organisation’s requirements.
When should organisations conduct reference and police checks?
Timing affects how efficiently the recruitment process runs. Many organisations screen in the later stages, once a preferred candidate has been identified. A typical process looks like this:
- Application review: assess the candidate’s application, experience and qualifications.
- Interview and assessment: evaluate suitability against the position requirements.
- Reference checks: contact nominated referees and verify relevant employment information.
- Police and background checks: request appropriate screening where the role requires it.
- Review and decision: consider the information alongside the other selection criteria.
- Offer and onboarding: proceed with the offer and onboarding, subject to any screening requirements.
For some roles, checks must be completed before an offer is made or before the employee starts work. Set clear procedures for conditional offers, outstanding checks and role-specific requirements. Once a candidate is hired, onboarding and offboarding take over the process.
Police and background checks in Australia and New Zealand
Employers should approach pre-employment screening carefully and make sure checks are relevant, lawful and well managed. Requirements and checking processes differ by type of check, position and jurisdiction. Keep these principles in mind:
- Obtain appropriate consent. Candidates should be told which checks are being requested and give the required consent or authorisation.
- Only request relevant checks. Screening should be proportionate to the responsibilities and risks of the position. Avoid collecting information that is not reasonably required.
- Consider results fairly. A result should not automatically decide whether a candidate is suitable. Consider relevance, context, applicable laws and the requirements of the position.
- Protect candidate information. Reference responses and screening results can contain personal and sensitive information. Manage access, storage, retention and disposal appropriately.
- Understand the applicable requirements. Australian employers should consider relevant privacy, discrimination and spent-conviction requirements, as well as the rules for the specific type of check. New Zealand employers should consider applicable privacy, human rights and criminal-record screening requirements, including the clean slate provisions where they apply.
For roles involving children or other vulnerable people, additional sector-specific screening and vetting requirements may apply. Seek legal or specialist advice if you are unsure about your obligations.
How recruitment software can help manage pre-employment checks
Managing screening manually creates extra work for HR teams and hiring managers. Reference requests, candidate communications, screening documents and follow-up can end up spread across emails, spreadsheets and separate service providers. Recruitment software brings more structure and visibility to these activities.
When evaluating a recruitment or applicant tracking system, check whether it supports:
- Recording candidate and application information
- Tracking recruitment stages
- Managing interview scheduling
- Recording reference-check progress
- Tracking outstanding screening requirements
- Managing relevant candidate communications
- Maintaining recruitment documentation
- Supporting recruitment reporting and analytics
The exact functionality depends on the software and any third-party screening services connected to it.
ActionHRM’s recruitment and applicant tracking capabilities support recruitment activities, including job-board integrations, automated screening, interview scheduling, offer letters, recruitment analytics and SMS integration. A structured process gives better visibility of candidate progress and helps manage recruitment tasks more consistently.
If you use an external reference-checking or police-check service, confirm how it works alongside your recruitment process and what integration or manual steps are needed.
Make pre-employment screening part of a better recruitment process
Reference checks and police checks are valuable when used appropriately. They help organisations gather more information about candidates, verify relevant experience and consider role-specific risks before an employment decision.
The greatest benefit comes from building screening into a consistent recruitment process, with clear responsibilities, open communication with candidates and careful handling of screening information.
Combine good recruitment practice with the right HR technology and you get better visibility across the hiring process and a more structured experience for candidates and hiring managers.
ActionHRM is a configurable HR management solution with recruitment and applicant tracking capabilities, helping organisations manage recruitment as part of the wider employee lifecycle. You can see the full range of HR solutions, how ActionHRM manages employee records, and why organisations choose ActionHRM.
Looking to improve your recruitment and screening processes? Contact ActionHRM to arrange a demonstration and see how ActionHRM can support your recruitment and HR management requirements.
Frequently asked questions
Why are reference checks important when hiring?
Reference checks give extra information about a candidate’s previous work experience, responsibilities, skills and professional conduct, helping employers make better-informed hiring decisions.
What is the purpose of a police check before employment?
A police check can provide relevant disclosable criminal history information to help employers assess suitability for positions where that information is relevant.
Should every employee undergo a police check?
Not necessarily. Checks should be appropriate and proportionate to the role, its responsibilities and any applicable legal or regulatory requirements.
When should reference and police checks be completed?
They are commonly completed in the later stages of recruitment. Timing depends on the role and on any requirements that must be met before employment starts.
Can recruitment software manage reference and police checks?
Recruitment software can help track screening requirements and candidate progress. Whether it can run checks directly, or integrate with external screening providers, depends on the software and the third-party services available.
How long are police checks valid?
There is no single validity period for all purposes. Requirements vary by employer, industry, jurisdiction and the organisation requesting the check.